"Just stopped for an Italian grinder because it’s been a minute. The guy running it is very friendly and cool to chat with!"
"I have to eat Gluten Free, and heard this Mancino's had GF options. The GF pizza was fantastic, and those with me that had their normal pizza loved it too.
Can't wait to try their Grinders! 😁"
"Friendly and FAST service! All the staff were very nice and helpful! We will definitely continue using them for our business lunches! Hanger Clinic Gaylord."
"We got 2 grinders to go, very good fresh and well made"
"The new owners are doing a great job at Mancino's in Gaylord. I pre-ordered three mixed grinder party platters for a luncheon for my co-workers. The communication, follow through, and customer service was great. Everyone at work was very pleased with thier lunch. They have way better service and food than the old Mancino's. 😋"
"The new owners are doing a great job at Mancino's in Gaylord. I pre-ordered three mixed grinder party platters for a luncheon for my co-workers. The communication, follow through, and customer service was great. Everyone at work was very pleased with thier lunch. They have way better service and food than the old Mancino's. 😋"
"This is our go to Pizza Place and we love it! Always fresh, clean and great food cooked to please! Thanks guys"
"The owner is always cooking the best pizza and the service is fantastic. Best pizza in town."
"If you are from Michigan, you know Mancino's. This might be the best Mancino's I've been to."
"I have ate at various Mancinos for 20+ years. This Mancinos is by far the best. They take quality very seriously. This my family's new pit spot as we travel from Genesee County to the UP."
"Employees were very friendly and owner came to our table and asked if our food was ok. I like that personal interest in the opinion of our food! Pizza and grinders were delicious!! If we are in the area again, we will definitely return to this Mancinos."
"Delicious food! My chicken sub was fantastic and my wife loved her brisket sub. And the stuffed bread sticks were divine. Thank you! Definitely returning there the next time I am in the area."
View More Reviews
Back To Top
"Delicious food! My chicken sub was fantastic and my wife loved her brisket sub. And the stuffed bread sticks were divine. Thank you! Definitely returning there the next time I am in the area."
"Amazing food . great staff!!!.
Not only a great place to eat, but if I were looking for a job that would definitely be a great place to work."
"Mancino's is an excellent clean family friendly environment to eat and work!!!!!"
"The pizza here is amazing. Fed the entire crew with less money than normal and we were all full."
"New owners spiffed up the restaurant. New soda fountain and attention to food quality. Our sandwiches were delicious."
"Was there yesterday got grinders they were amazing and was super nice and took good care of us."
"Great little place for affordable grinders, pizza, and "basic" pasta dishes. The staff is friendly, restaurant is centrally located, and there is never a wait. Try the grinders, you won't be disappointed!"
"Went in for a grinder one day, smelled the pizza, and two days later- ordered one. Yum! Never going anywhere else."
"I had been wanting mancinos for a bit. I used to get on the regular years ago. Stumbled here and it took me right back. Food was hot and tasty. The staff was so great. Having fun. Polite. Fast.. really refreshing to have the great experience I remembered. I look forward to going back."
"Fun retro Italian diner. Food was fast, hot, fresh and delicious! We are traveling and took a chance. No Regrets!"
"Staff there was very kind, prices are great, food was amazing and we got it in no time! If I could give this place 100 stars, I would!"
"I'm out of town, and wanted something warm. Got the club and fries. The club was comparable to Kazoopys, and the fries were like steak for bar fries - still good cold. Delivery was fast and I'm happy to recommend."
"Great sandwiches!! A mistake was made and they corrected it immediately. Superb staff."
"The sub was great, I love subs and are always getting subway, lemme tell you this a way better, not even close it's 2 different worlds, one of the best subs I ever had."
"Stopped in today for a quick anniversary lunch with my wife, Paula.
We were pleasantly greeted the moment we walked in, our order was hot and fresh and prepared with care (a welcome change from the usual thrown together fast food). We were left full and satisfied.
Thank you to Nicole and staff for a thoroughly enjoyable and delicious experience! We will be back!"
"Walked in to place an order. Employee from back ...name? I need to place order, give me a sec. All associates were in back now and didn't come back after a couple minutes. So I left. Was going to order to full grinders, but....
Edit update:
Owner reached out to me. Her kindness and care for her business shows. What was a 1 star is now 5. Yes, this shouldn't have happened. But she made an effort to make it right. Great customer service. I will try again next time I am in town. Thank you"
"Service was a little slow, pop machine was down which is okay, they did have expired pops in their cooler though.
The food was great and came out slightly quicker than expected."
"Pizza is delicious and cheesy bread to die for .. keep up the great work and delicious food"
"Have not had Mancinos in years. My BLT sub was as good as I remember from back in the day. Delicious!!!"
"The greatest baked ham & cheese sub on earth. I've been to every Mancinos I can find, and they never disappoint. 👍"
"Food is always great, keeps us coming back. Today was especially great service. I had left my purse there by accident, I was 45 minutes away when I realized it. I called the restaurant and while on hold they checked for my purse found it and I went back and picked it up. Everything was still there so I want to give a big thank you to today's staff. We will be back to see you again your the best."
"Best sandwich in town for the price and taste 😋. My only sandwich shop,replacing JJ 😜"
"I ordered the spicy Italian grinder and it was delicious it fed me for 2 days"
"Food was bomb. One of the workers did set raw pork chops package down where she was food prepping."
"Pizza grinder for the win. I have made this a regular stop on my trips into Troll Land from the UP. Can't beat it for the taste of growing up (Alpena)."
"Always a favorite stop for us when in town. Restaurant was super busy so had to get to go. Everything was made as ordered and delicious as usual!"
"Just had the best sandwich I’ve had in ages (club). Staff were friendly. Food was well priced. Would absolutely return. 10/10"
"Their Italian grinder is one of my favorite sandwiches ever! Maybe it's just the nostalgia from eating it when I was in high school. I have traveled around the world and had many delicious sandwiches. I'm not trying to say it's the best sandwich I've ever had but it is one of my favorites!"
"I love the food I love staff and for the inflation these prices are very reasonable👍 Thank you Mancinos you are my favorite pizza place in Michigan ❤️"
"Finally found a pizza we both loved AND no indigestion/heartburn later!! Awesome pizza, we'll be back. Thank you!"
"These people are people are amazing! Thank you all so much for the wonderful service always."
"The young man that waited on us with the red coloring in his hair was so sweet and friendly! We had a Rueben & pizza grinder they were delicious fresh and hot the bread was the best we have ever had! Next time we are up this way we will definitely stop again the atmosphere is super clean and so cool how it’s in what used to be a bank!!"
"We came from Wisconsin to vend at Shipshewana Craft Fair and were feeling pizza. We found this place on google maps so thought we would try it. Hands down the best pizza I ever had. I had the BLT pizza and oh my was it delicious. My husband had a sausage pizza and cheese bread with bacon and he really liked his too. The staff was super friendly and several of them checked on us, very polite guys you have working there. Great job, we will definitely be back every time were in town!"
"The staff was super friendly, quick, and accurate! The restaurant was clean same with the restroom! My food was excellent. I definitely recommend eating here, and I will be back next time I'm in town."
"Love this location, it's spacious and well organized. The staff is always friendly and the food is amazing."
"Stopped in to put in a multiple orders to take back home for and the people were friendly and had my orders ready in no time."
"Food was very good, exactly what you'd expected for a Mancino's. They also have fresh made cookies, I highly recommend trying them!
Service was so welcoming and genuine, made our experience extremely enjoyable!"
"We had Italian grinders and poppers, good was really good and staff was really friendly"
"I absolutely love Mancino’s subs. They are the best in the town. I would recommend anyone looking for a family friendly place to have and get food here you go."
"The food was good! I had been craving pasta for awhile, so tried theires for the first time! They did not disappoint! Hubby got a sub, he very much enjoyed it! People are very nice and helpful!"
"Such a cute place! It was very clean the dining room, eatery way and the kitchen from the looks of it! The cashier was really helpful and so sweet too! The building was pretty cute as well. There was people coming and going that seemed to know the staff well like regulars so that was cool too. It definitely has a small town home feeling vibe! My food was great as was my guests."
"From Cincinnati here visiting my father. The food was hot and delicious. Service was good. Only thing I didn't like was the guy in the kitchen complaining about what people ordered. If you don't like your job, find a new one."
"When in Gaylord, we often pick up our pizza. This time we chose to dine in. The restaurant was clean and the staff friendly and helpful. We ordered a special pizza with four different varieties of pepperoni and it was absolutely delicious. Plenty of pepperoni and cheese. Baked perfectly."
"Catering we had to wait a little past the time, but they were very helpful, food was delicious."
"Food is fast service was great grinders are fantastic pizza is really good pasta is great."
"Will come to gaylords mancino before ill travel to petoskey. Gaylords manico is by far the best! Thank you Elizabeth for all you did for us 🍽"
"Lizee rocks-excellent food and crew! Everyone still whimpering , , crying and overworking their employees ? Come study this place- they're on point!"
"Had the French Dip hoagie and it was delish. Even served with a container of aus jus with a tight fit lid for leftover take-home. Highly recommend."
"They have a soup bar with at least 6 different soups. It's a wonderful lunch."
"Absolutely, positively, hands down, without a doubt the best place to eat in Gaylord. I ordered delivery and it was fantastic!"
"Always consistently good. When the grinders were boxed for takeout. Wrapping the grinders makes them soggy."
"By far mine and my husbands favorite place to grab a quick grinder while we are passing through. Never had a problem ordering and receiving the right thing online. Staff is always friendly, grinders are done at a decent time, and they are ALWAYS delicious!"
"Their food is SO BOMB!!! They also have gluten free and vegetarian options as well. Check them out!"
"They have the absolute best grinders. The only downfall is there was way too much sauce used and by the time I got my grinder home it was soggy. Lighten up on the sauce on grinders.. other then that the flavor was so good! I am from lapeer county and when I moved to Gaylord and seen Mancinos.. I was in heaven"
"I have one of these by my home and you did not disappoint me at all! Very good."
"Such good food for the inexpensive prices! We ordered chicken broccoli Alfredo pasta, which was topped with melted cheese and two very delicious pieces of garlic bread. The personal pizza and cookie were yummy too!
We ordered our food on DoorDash and was waiting in the parking lot, and somehow the kind employee knew it was us and brought the food to our car at exactly the estimated ready time on the app. Pleasantly surprised by the five star service!"
"Wow! FINALLY found the best pizza in Michigan! This was, without a doubt, our favorite meal in a restaurant of any kind in the last 4 years. Pizza was perfect. Garlic cheese bread and chicken wings were great. Cannot wait to try the grinders. Worth the drive from Lewiston. Thank you for a wonderful meal!!"
"Mancinos is always great 😚. Fresh and
Super tasty 😋. Love the Italian it's got
All the good stuff 😉."
"New owners. Seem to be great people. I hope the best for them. Same great food with their new additions. I love the Lumberjack! For my money, one of the best sandwiches I have had. My wife had the pizza she liked it."
"Food was good! Pizza crust & sauce excellent; Grinder was delicious; we got #1. Service was excellent. We were there @ 3PM on Wednesday."
"Mancinos is always delicious. Been awhile since we've had and didn't disappoint"
"Stopped in today for a quick lunch. Staff were friendly, service was quick, and food tasted delicious! Thank!"
"Excellent service and fast delivery…especially for specialty orders that included gluten free and other requests!"
"Stopped in on my way home from a snowmobile trip .grinders were amazing will be stopping in again .. ladies working behind the counter were very outgoing and make u feel welcome"
"I'm kicking myself now, for not getting her name, but to the blonde woman who held my pizza for me last night- You made our night! I had ordered a pizza at about 8:35pm, figuring I would pick it up after I got out of work at 9. I didnt realize that Mancinos closes at 9 as well, so i called them to apologize & let them know i would be late picking it up. The woman was so nice & understanding, & even threw in a little treat & i cant thank her enough. That night, I had a group of people who had been out in the cold for 8+ hours depending on me for dinner! All said, I just wanted to at least review them for their excellent customer service & the pizza tasted great too!"
"I have to travel down to the Lower Peninsula a lot from the UP and this Mancino’s is my go to lunch spot!"
"One of the best meat lovers pizza we ate. Staff was friendly, service was very efficient."
"Awesome!!! Great food friendly staff my first time being their!!! My husband never eats a full piece of pizza he cant find one done right but their he ate the whole piece!!! Not just picking the toppings off!!!! Great job guys!!!!!"
"Delicious! I miss not having a Mancino's down state! So ever time I come up north I have to stop here! Chicken grinder is killer! Pizza grinder is pretty good too!"
"Already love Mancinos, this one is the best one visited. Awesome staff, professional and oh yeah the food was great too."
"Great sense of service. Good people skills just shooting the breeze while waiting for oven 2 finnish. Attentive obligation as new staff entered trying to help me as i waited. Great food as usual thank you. Fast forward 1-29-25 new management I arrived at 7 minutes to close a young gentlemen, dark hair was totally ready even though everything was clean (and I mean it was clean like clean clean) to go ahead and mess everything up to make me and my friend food. I explained to him. I have been where you are and I will never do that to anyone in the food service industry. Everything is turned down. We're good. Have a great night, it's my fault. Somehow he didn't think I was genuine and was literally pushing me to put food in the oven at 3 minutes to close, really dude please after complete tear down and clean up. This man deserves a raise purely upon his dedication to service. I will be calling you tomorrow on my smoke. Break. Manager. I don't know his name. I really regret not getting it, but manager this guy is awesome."
"Mancinos of Gaylord has soups! As of October 2021. Excellent, and hearty. $4 for a bowl (2 cups), 2.69 for a cup. Eat inside at the soup bar for a better deal."
"If you want fast, friendly service and fresh, hot, DELICIOUS food, than Mancino's of Gaylord is the place to go! Everything from the baked wings down to a simple pepperoni pizza was absolutely wonderful. You have a customer for life!"
"We have never had a bad experience with the Gaylord store. The staff is always friendly, and the owners are awesome. Looking forward to stopping in again."
"Never knew what a grinder was until I moved here (Originally from Alabama). They were fast making me one and friendly. It was definitely a great grinder and I’ll be back to get another one.
-Local Air Force Recruiter"
"The food is good for what it is. Decently priced with good portions that you can share. The grinder was especially yummy.
Only downside is that they seem to be closed randomly throughout th week/day. So always have a back up plan when coming through Gaylord."
"Got the seafood grinder. It was good. Also like the veggie grinder and garlic cheese bread."
"Great place to grab a bite when traveling up north. Just off the highway and the call ahead works great."
"Best pizza I can remember having in some time, and Italian grinder was amazing as well."
"Fabric shopping for new quilts! Nancy, the owner is so friendly and super nice. Shop is loaded with beautiful fabrics, notions, and so models. Plenty of ideas to get your creative juices flowing!"
"Absolutely love the grinders. My food is always great. My favorite hot sub shop. Definitely best in town. I love the new location and drive thru."
"First timer, got a grinder and was not disappointed. Very good quality. Will be a repeat customer for sure."
"Unbelievably good grinders! And the gluten free bread is so good you won't even believe it's gluten free."
"Tried this for the first time since moving up here...AMAZING. We got the club grinder, garlic knots, and a personal pepperoni pizza for our son and everything was freshly prepared and filling.
Won’t be going anywhere else from now on."
"Ordered via phone call and had exemplary service! You don't always get good customer service anymore! Good job Mancinos!"
"They have really good food and some you may not expect like french fries and they have a tasty tacos salad"
"My first time to order from Mancino's. We picked our order up no problems. My husband and I shared a Lumberjack grinder. They cut the full grinder into 4's which was great. One of these could feed 4 people with a side of something. Great flavors, loved the bun, fresh ingredients, yum! The full grinder is in a long box for To Go orders which travels perfect for picnics."
"Went back after a bad experience and my food was great we were very pleased."
"Best pizza in Gaylord. And Celiac friendly with a great tasting gluten free pizza"
"Great place to eat! Staff is friendly, and the food is always out very quick, they never dissapoint!"
"We were very impressed with the service. They were glad we were there and wanted to serve us. The food came out quick and was delicious."
"We moved into the area a little over 2 years ago and when I saw we had a Mancino's, I was stoked!! I hadn't had Mancino's in YEARS! I was nervous about ordering the pizza because the last Mancino's I had from another area was disgusting. But we finally decided to try it (we usually get the PHENOMENAL grinders), and the pizza is delicious, too! Always hot and delicious. Thank you!"
"Used Mancino's catering for a large party a day before our wedding. We had several pizzas and grinders ordered and all of the food was very hot and delivered on time.
Zero complaints, in fact we received multiple comments about how good the pizza was."
"This place is the best place for grinders I love the spicy Italian and the A1 bomber. I recommend this place to anyone I can it is so good."
"Food was absolutely phenomenal! So yummy! Grinders were the best tasting ever!!!"
"Not worth your money. New owners are serving food that if I went to Walmart I can make better."
"This is my favorite place to eat in Gaylord. Quality food, affordable price, quick pick up. Staff is friendly. Daily specials are a great bargain, menu has a large selection. Pizza and grinders are both excellent."
"Very good food .Very good employees .Fresh food. And fast service .Need I say more.??"
"Thank you to Amy! She's amazing! She put together a grinder for our daughter who is allergic to gluten and dairy! It really made her day and it was delicious! Thank you so much for taking the time to do this! All of our other grinders were delicious! We always come to eat lunch during Big ticket festival! Looking forward to see you again next year!! God Bless you!❤"
"Super fresh food. Great tasting and made in a timely manner. Sometimes super fast lol. Keep up the amazing job!!"
"Something's going on here, all new help. Ordered pizza, not like it used to be. Will keep trying and see what happens.."
"The managers went out of their way to make my daughter's gluten free grinders, including getting the toppings out of new containers. This is the only Mancinos that has the Lumberjack grinder."
"When I am travelling from the UP to the Detroit Area. It is the most convenient location to stop to get the best sandwich..."
"Delicious crust! Crisp on the bottom yet soft and delicious in the middle. Top quality ingredients; medium was baked just right!"
"The best subs in Gaylord! The bread is baked fresh there. We tried the ham and salami sub and it's delicious."
"Honestly best service at any pizza restaurant ever. Quick delivery or pick up quality food and amazing service. Thank you!"
"pizza and grinders. what's a grinder? it's a toasted sandwich with any filling you want (also known as pudgy pie). I got the pizza grinder. veggies were free. it was delicious and was about $6.50, and came out quick. thumbs up!"
"16" subs are amazing and are good for at least 2 meals. they cut them into easy 4 piece slices of sandwich. i loved the pizza sub."
"Good place to catch a bite and take a break while traveling. They have lots of grinders, Both large and half size. Just the half is enough. We also got cheese bread with it. I would suggest this establishment to anyone looking for something to eat when in town."
"First, the smell of this place is AMAZING!!!! Second, the subs are EXCELLENT!!!! Third, the ice cream cookie sandwiches are everything I thought they would be and more!!!!"
"Super good grinders, plus they got my picky order just right. Will come back"
"Always The Best.
From The Services To The Food.
Always The Best.
We provide menus to All Of Our
Members And Guest...
Because at Mancino’s of Gaylord....
It’s Always The Best.
They Really Go The Extra Mile...
Thank-You Gaylord Mancino’s.
Lynn @ Benjamin’sBeaverCreekResort."
"Mancinos has the most courteous staff ever. The pizza was phenomenal and i got it in 25 minutes. Awesome!!!"
"Exceptional service, clean and modern atmosphere and the quality of ingredients make the best tasting calzone I've ever had."
"They have such good food and such good prices. You definitely get alot of food for the price. Subs are so good and pizza😊"
"Great food! Great time , clean store , just the lady with the smokers voice not real honest , asked for dressing on the side , she claims we did not ask for it on the side but it was written on the ticket."
"Has the best pizza in town...hands down. The variety is awesome, especially for there subs. Never had a bad experience. Have specials on the weekdays, Monday thru Thursday."
"I love their Hawaiian meat lovers pizza it's seriously the most delicious thing I ever tasted"
"Amazing pasta and grinders! Mancino's in Gaylord provides wonderful service, and great food! Friendly staff and service in a timely manor. I highly recommend this Mancino's if you're craving some great pasta. They will even customize everything for you!"
"Great food, but they always close earlier then their posted time. Says 9pm, but closed by 7pm?"
"I stop at this place whenever I drive through Gaylord. Their grinders are just so tasty."
"The best place for grinders I've ever been to. Better than "Grinderz", and "Bellacino's" hands down. The pizza is also amazing, however, I haven't had the chance to try the other pizza in town, so I don't know if there's anything better. But the food overall, and the service is great. What a great place to eat!
I come to Gaylord once/twice a year for golf and skiing, and it's always my must stop, go-to destination when it comes to a quick casual meal!"